WASHINGTON D.C. – January 20, 2020 – The traditional landscape of medical error disclosure and resolution is undergoing a profound transformation, driven by a growing recognition that true healing extends far beyond legal settlements. On January 16, the Collaborative Alliance for Patient Safety (CAPS) hosted a seminal webinar titled "Healing after Harm," bringing to the forefront innovative approaches like Restorative Practice and Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR). This crucial discussion, now available on the CAPS webpage (patientsafety.org), underscored a paradigm shift: how healthcare institutions respond to harm can either perpetuate suffering or pave a path toward genuine recovery for all involved parties – patients, their families, and the dedicated healthcare providers.
n
The webinar provided a sobering definition of "harm" within the healthcare context: "Ill treatment; the impairment of physical or mental health (including that suffered from seeing, or hearing another person suffer ill treatment)." This comprehensive definition acknowledges the ripple effect of adverse events, impacting not only the directly affected patient but also their loved ones and the often traumatized caregivers involved. The central thesis presented by CAPS and its expert speakers was clear: the manner in which harm is addressed holds the power to mitigate or, conversely, exacerbate an already tragic situation.
n
The session featured compelling insights from Mary Ellen Mannix, whose personal tragedy ignited a quest for meaningful healing, and Martin Hatlie, a leading voice in patient safety and the evolution of CANDOR. Their combined expertise illuminated a forward-thinking framework designed to replace the historically adversarial response to medical errors with one rooted in empathy, transparency, and restoration. The overwhelming engagement from attendees, reflected in numerous questions, prompted CAPS to schedule a follow-up discussion on Thursday, January 30, 2020, at Noon Central Time, further solidifying the urgent need for continued dialogue on these critical practices.
n
n
Main Facts
n
The "Healing after Harm" webinar, presented by the Collaborative Alliance for Patient Safety (CAPS) on January 16, served as a pivotal platform for discussing advanced methodologies in addressing medical harm. The core objective was to explore how healthcare systems can move beyond conventional legalistic responses to foster genuine healing for all stakeholders impacted by adverse events.
n
Key takeaways from the webinar included:
n
- n
- A Broadened Definition of Harm: Emphasizing physical, mental, and vicarious suffering, underscoring the widespread impact of medical errors.
- The Power of Restorative Practice: Introduced by Mary Ellen Mannix, this social science focuses on repairing relationships and fostering healing for patients, caregivers, and providers by removing shame and facilitating a path forward. Mannix’s personal narrative highlighted the inadequacy of legal remedies alone for true emotional and psychological recovery.
- CANDOR as a Restorative Tool: Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR) was presented by Martin Hatlie as a practical application of Restorative Practice principles within healthcare. Hatlie detailed CANDOR’s evolution from the AHRQ Seven Pillars Tool Kit, emphasizing its structured approach to post-event management.
- Widespread Adoption of CANDOR: Evidence of CANDOR’s growing acceptance was provided, with its implementation in over 200 hospitals across 35 states, signaling a significant shift in institutional responses to harm.
- Call for Continued Engagement: The high volume of attendee questions regarding implementation strategies led CAPS to promptly schedule a follow-up discussion, demonstrating the immediate and pressing need for practical guidance on these transformative practices.
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
Chronology
n
The Genesis of a Critical Dialogue: Shifting Paradigms in Patient Safety
n
For decades, the standard response to medical errors in healthcare was often characterized by a "deny and defend" posture. This approach, while perhaps intended to protect institutions, frequently left patients and families feeling unheard and uncompensated, while healthcare providers grappled with guilt and fear, often in isolation. The imperative for change became increasingly evident with landmark reports, such as the Institute of Medicine’s "To Err Is Human" in 1999, which starkly highlighted the preventable nature of medical errors and their devastating impact.
n
In the ensuing years, a growing movement for patient safety began to advocate for greater transparency, accountability, and a more compassionate approach. Organizations like CAPS emerged as champions of this new era, dedicated to fostering environments where learning from errors, rather than concealing them, becomes paramount. Recognizing that legal and financial resolutions alone often fail to address the profound emotional and psychological wounds inflicted by harm, CAPS identified the need for a deeper, more holistic framework for healing. This understanding laid the groundwork for the "Healing after Harm" webinar, conceived as a vital step in advancing this critical conversation within the broader healthcare community. The selection of Restorative Practice and CANDOR reflected CAPS’s commitment to showcasing evidence-based, human-centered solutions.
n
January 16th: A Landmark Webinar Unveiling Restorative Paths
n
The "Healing after Harm" webinar commenced on January 16 with a clear agenda: to challenge conventional wisdom and introduce proven methodologies for navigating the aftermath of medical harm. The virtual format allowed for broad participation, drawing a diverse audience of healthcare administrators, clinicians, patient advocates, and legal professionals.
n
Mary Ellen Mannix opened the session with a deeply personal and poignant narrative. Following the tragic death of her son due to medical error, Mannix embarked on a relentless pursuit of justice, initially through legal channels. However, she candidly shared that while legal recourse might offer some form of accountability, it did not, by itself, lead to emotional healing. This powerful realization propelled her into the study of Restorative Practice. She elucidated Restorative Practice not merely as a set of techniques but as a fundamental social science dedicated to improving and repairing relationships between individuals and within communities. Mannix articulated how its principles – focusing on repairing harm, fostering dialogue, ensuring accountability, and reintegrating all parties – could be profoundly transformative in healthcare. By actively working to remove the pervasive shame often associated with medical errors, Restorative Practice allows patients, caregivers, and providers to engage in honest dialogue, understand the full impact of the harm, and collaboratively forge a path forward. She powerfully conveyed that this process is not about assigning blame but about understanding needs and finding mutually acceptable ways to heal and move on.
n
Following Mannix, Martin Hatlie, a respected figure in the patient safety movement, took the virtual stage to elaborate on Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR). Hatlie positioned CANDOR as a practical, structured application of Restorative Practice principles within the complex healthcare environment. He meticulously traced CANDOR’s origins, explaining how it evolved from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality’s (AHRQ) "Seven Pillars Tool Kit." This foundational toolkit provided a comprehensive framework for patient safety initiatives, and CANDOR distilled its essence into a actionable program designed specifically for post-event management. Hatlie highlighted what can be inferred as the three basic tenets of CANDOR:
n
- n
- Open and Timely Communication & Apology: Emphasizing proactive, honest, and empathetic communication with patients and families immediately following an adverse event, coupled with a sincere apology.
- Thorough and Transparent Investigation: A commitment to understanding "what happened and why" through objective, non-punitive analysis, sharing findings with affected parties.
- Fair Resolution & Comprehensive Support: Offering appropriate and timely resolution, which may include financial compensation, but also non-financial remedies, coupled with robust support systems for both patients/families and the involved healthcare providers, often referred to as "second victims."
n
n
n
n
Hatlie provided compelling evidence of CANDOR’s real-world impact, citing its successful implementation in over 200 hospitals across 35 states. This widespread adoption underscores not only the program’s efficacy but also a growing institutional readiness to embrace a more transparent and humane response to medical harm. The webinar concluded with a vibrant Q&A session, signaling the audience’s deep interest and the practical challenges associated with integrating these innovative practices into existing healthcare systems.
n
Post-Webinar Engagement and Future Steps
The immediate aftermath of the "Healing after Harm" webinar was characterized by an enthusiastic and inquisitive response from attendees. The sheer volume and depth of questions regarding the practical implementation of Restorative Practice and CANDOR underscored a critical need for further discussion and guidance. Many participants sought clarification on logistical challenges, cultural shifts required, and specific strategies for embedding these principles within their own organizations.
Recognizing this palpable demand for continued engagement, CAPS swiftly responded by scheduling a follow-up discussion. This subsequent session, slated for Thursday, January 30, 2020, at Noon Central Time, is designed to serve as an interactive forum. It will allow attendees to delve deeper into their queries, share experiences, and collectively explore solutions for overcoming barriers to implementation. The meeting details were promptly disseminated, inviting all interested parties to join via computer, tablet, or smartphone through a dedicated GoToMeeting link, or by dialing in using a provided phone number and access code. This proactive step by CAPS reinforced its commitment to not just presenting ideas but also fostering a community of practice dedicated to translating these transformative concepts into tangible improvements in patient safety and healing.
Supporting Data
The Pervasive Challenge of Healthcare Harm
The urgency behind initiatives like "Healing after Harm" is rooted in the sobering reality of medical error’s prevalence and its devastating consequences. Decades after the initial calls for reform, adverse events remain a significant public health challenge. Studies continue to estimate that hundreds of thousands of patients suffer preventable harm, and tens of thousands die annually, due to medical errors in U.S. hospitals. These statistics represent not just numbers but countless individual tragedies, leading to prolonged suffering, disability, and immense emotional distress for patients and their families.
Beyond the direct physical and financial costs, the emotional and psychological toll of healthcare harm is profound. Patients often experience a deep sense of betrayal and loss of trust in the very system designed to heal them. Families, in turn, bear the burden of grief, anger, and the complex navigation of a healthcare system that may seem opaque and unresponsive. Equally critical, though often overlooked, is the impact on healthcare providers themselves. These "second victims" of medical errors experience significant psychological distress, including anxiety, depression, guilt, and even post-traumatic stress. This can lead to burnout, decreased job satisfaction, and a reluctance to report errors, thereby perpetuating a cycle of silence and missed opportunities for learning. The pervasive nature of harm, and its multi-faceted impact, therefore, necessitates comprehensive, empathetic, and effective strategies for healing and prevention.
Evidence for Restorative Practice: A Framework for Repair
Restorative Practice, while gaining traction in healthcare, has a robust theoretical and empirical foundation in other fields, notably criminal justice, education, and community building. Its core principles are centered on repairing harm and relationships rather than solely punishing wrongdoers. Key elements include:
- Voluntary Participation: All parties involved in the harm must willingly engage in the process.
- Dialogue and Storytelling: Creating safe spaces for individuals to share their experiences, feelings, and needs.
- Focus on Harm and Needs: Shifting the conversation from "who is to blame?" to "who has been harmed and what do they need?"
- Accountability and Responsibility: Encouraging those who caused harm to take responsibility for their actions and actively participate in making amends.
- Consensus-Based Solutions: Collaboratively developing solutions that address the identified needs and repair relationships.
- Reintegration: Helping all parties move forward and reintegrate into their respective communities.
In healthcare, applying Restorative Practice principles can transform the aftermath of an adverse event. Instead of an adversarial process, it facilitates a human-centered dialogue where patients and families can express their pain and ask questions, and providers can offer genuine apologies, explain what happened, and commit to learning. This approach has been shown to improve patient and family satisfaction, reduce litigation, and foster a more supportive environment for healthcare professionals, promoting a culture of learning over blame. Studies, though still emerging specifically in healthcare, from other sectors demonstrate its effectiveness in improving communication, fostering empathy, and building stronger, more resilient communities.
The Efficacy of CANDOR: A Proactive Solution
The Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR) process, championed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), represents a pragmatic and evidence-informed application of restorative justice principles within healthcare. Martin Hatlie’s report of CANDOR’s implementation in "over 200 hospitals" across "35 states" is not merely a statistic; it signifies a substantial shift in how a significant portion of the U.S. healthcare system is addressing medical harm.
The benefits of CANDOR are multi-fold and supported by empirical observations from its implementation:
- Improved Patient and Family Satisfaction: Open, honest, and timely communication, coupled with genuine apologies and offers of resolution, significantly enhances trust and satisfaction among affected patients and families. They feel heard, respected, and involved in the process, rather than marginalized.
- Reduced Litigation and Costs: By addressing concerns proactively and offering fair resolution, CANDOR programs have been shown to reduce the incidence of malpractice lawsuits. This leads to substantial savings in legal defense costs, insurance premiums, and settlements. Institutions can often resolve issues more quickly and fairly outside of protracted court battles.
- Enhanced Provider Well-being and Psychological Safety: CANDOR provides a structured support system for healthcare providers involved in adverse events, mitigating the "second victim" phenomenon. By fostering a "just culture" where errors are viewed as learning opportunities rather than solely punishable offenses, providers are more likely to report errors, participate in investigations, and remain engaged in their work. This support is crucial for reducing burnout and improving staff morale.
- Systemic Learning and Prevention: The transparent investigation component of CANDOR ensures that lessons learned from adverse events are systematically incorporated into institutional practices, leading to robust system improvements and a reduction in future occurrences of harm. This continuous learning cycle is fundamental to advancing patient safety.
The "three basic tenets" of CANDOR, as inferred from its comprehensive framework – open communication and apology, thorough investigation, and fair resolution with comprehensive support – collectively create an environment where healing, learning, and prevention can genuinely flourish. The widespread adoption data underscores its proven utility as a viable, humane, and economically sensible alternative to traditional "deny and defend" strategies.
Official Responses
CAPS’s Leadership in Patient Safety
The Collaborative Alliance for Patient Safety (CAPS) has long stood as a beacon in the patient safety movement, and the "Healing after Harm" webinar is a testament to its ongoing commitment. As a non-profit organization, CAPS’s mission is fundamentally centered on fostering safer healthcare environments through education, advocacy, and the promotion of best practices. This webinar perfectly aligns with its broader strategic goals of reducing preventable harm and enhancing the overall quality of patient care. By bringing together leading experts and facilitating a national dialogue on Restorative Practice and CANDOR, CAPS demonstrates its leadership in identifying and championing innovative solutions to complex healthcare challenges. The organization’s proactive scheduling of a follow-up discussion further reinforces its dedication not just to presenting ideas, but to actively nurturing their understanding and implementation within the healthcare community. This initiative positions CAPS as a crucial catalyst for cultural transformation in patient safety.
AHRQ’s Endorsement and Development of CANDOR
The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ), a division of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, plays a pivotal role in shaping patient safety initiatives through research and the development of practical tools. Martin Hatlie’s explanation of CANDOR’s evolution from the "AHRQ Seven Pillars Tool Kit" highlights the profound influence of this federal agency. AHRQ’s endorsement and development of CANDOR lent significant credibility and a robust, evidence-based foundation to the program.
The "Seven Pillars Tool Kit" provided healthcare organizations with a comprehensive roadmap for improving safety culture, promoting teamwork, and managing adverse events. CANDOR built upon this foundation by offering a specific, actionable framework for responding effectively and compassionately when harm does occur. AHRQ’s involvement signals a strong governmental recognition of the need for transparent, patient-centered approaches to medical error. It underscores the shift from a punitive, blame-focused culture to one that prioritizes learning, accountability, and healing. This official backing has been instrumental in encouraging widespread adoption of CANDOR across the nation, providing healthcare systems with a federally vetted and supported model for managing challenging situations with integrity and empathy.
Healthcare Systems Embracing Transparency
The reported adoption of CANDOR practices in "over 200 hospitals" across "35 states" reflects a significant and encouraging trend within the broader healthcare industry. This widespread embrace signals a growing recognition among healthcare leaders and administrators that transparency and proactive communication are not just ethical imperatives but also strategically sound practices. For decades, fear of litigation often led institutions to adopt a defensive stance, which ultimately eroded patient trust and hindered opportunities for systemic learning.
The shift towards CANDOR demonstrates a maturation of institutional policy, prioritizing open dialogue, sincere apologies, and fair resolution. This cultural transformation indicates a willingness to move beyond the traditional "deny and defend" mentality towards a more humane and just approach. It suggests that healthcare systems are increasingly understanding that by being transparent and supportive, they can rebuild trust with patients, improve staff morale, and ultimately create safer environments for everyone. This movement is not merely a response to external pressures but an internal commitment to ethical care and continuous improvement, signaling a profound evolution in how healthcare organizations perceive their responsibilities in the wake of adverse events.
Implications
Reshaping the Landscape of Healthcare Accountability
The introduction and growing adoption of Restorative Practice and CANDOR are fundamentally reshaping the landscape of accountability in healthcare. Historically, accountability for medical errors was often equated with blame, punishment, and legal repercussions. This adversarial framework frequently led to protracted legal battles, immense emotional distress for all parties, and ultimately, did little to foster genuine healing or prevent future harm.
Restorative Practice and CANDOR offer a powerful alternative, transforming accountability from a punitive measure into a collaborative process. They shift the focus from "who is to blame?" to "what happened, who was affected, and what needs to be done to repair the harm and prevent recurrence?" This approach encourages open dialogue, shared understanding, and a collective commitment to making things right. By fostering environments where providers feel safe to report errors and engage in honest conversations, these practices cultivate a "just culture" – one that holds individuals accountable for their choices but recognizes that systems, not just individuals, often contribute to errors. This redefinition of accountability is crucial for fostering a healthcare system that is not only safer but also more compassionate and resilient.
Fostering Trust and Psychological Safety
Perhaps the most profound implication of embracing Restorative Practice and CANDOR is their potential to rebuild and strengthen trust within the healthcare ecosystem. Trust, once broken by medical error, is incredibly difficult to restore. However, proactive communication, sincere apologies, transparent investigations, and fair resolutions, all central to CANDOR, can be powerful mechanisms for re-establishing patient and family confidence. When patients feel heard, respected, and involved in the resolution process, their sense of agency is restored, and the healing journey can truly begin.
Concurrently, these practices significantly enhance psychological safety for healthcare providers. The "second victim" phenomenon is a testament to the immense emotional burden carried by clinicians involved in adverse events. By providing structured support, avenues for honest disclosure without fear of undue punishment, and opportunities for learning, Restorative Practice and CANDOR mitigate this burden. This increased psychological safety not only supports the well-being of individual providers but also encourages a culture of open reporting and continuous improvement, which is vital for preventing future errors. When both patients and providers feel psychologically safe, the entire healthcare system benefits from enhanced communication, greater empathy, and a collective commitment to patient safety.
The Path Forward: Integration and Education
The journey towards universal adoption of Restorative Practice and CANDOR is ongoing, but the momentum generated by events like the CAPS webinar is undeniable. The immediate demand for a follow-up discussion underscores the critical need for continued education, practical training, and sustained organizational commitment. Successful integration requires more than just policy changes; it necessitates a deep cultural shift within healthcare institutions. This involves training all levels of staff – from frontline clinicians to senior administrators – in communication skills, empathetic listening, and the principles of restorative justice.
Looking ahead, the path forward involves:
- Wider Dissemination of Best Practices: Sharing successful implementation models and lessons learned from the 200+ hospitals already employing CANDOR.
- Curriculum Integration: Incorporating Restorative Practice and CANDOR principles into medical, nursing, and healthcare administration education.
- Advocacy and Policy Support: Continuing to advocate for state and federal policies that support transparency, apology, and fair resolution programs.
- Ongoing Research: Further investigating the long-term impacts on patient outcomes, provider well-being, and cost-effectiveness.
The "Healing after Harm" webinar represents a pivotal moment in the ongoing evolution of patient safety. By championing Restorative Practice and CANDOR, CAPS and its partners are not merely addressing the aftermath of harm; they are actively building a more transparent, compassionate, and ultimately, safer future for healthcare. The scheduled follow-up discussion on January 30, 2020, stands as a testament to the enduring commitment to this vital work, inviting all stakeholders to continue contributing to a healthcare environment where healing is prioritized, and trust can truly flourish.
Please join my meeting from your computer, tablet or smartphone.
https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/369235157
You can also dial in using your phone.
United States: +1 (872) 240-3212
Access Code: 369-235-157
