FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
n
Washington, D.C. – January 20, 2020 – The landscape of patient safety and error resolution in healthcare is undergoing a profound transformation, moving from traditional adversarial approaches to models centered on healing, transparency, and restoration. This critical shift was the central theme of the recent webinar, "Healing after Harm," presented by the Collaborative Alliance for Patient Safety (CAPS) on January 16th. Featuring insights from patient advocate Mary Ellen Mannix and patient safety expert Martin Hatlie, the virtual event underscored the power of Restorative Practice and Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR) in fostering recovery for all parties affected by healthcare harm.
n
The webinar, now available for review under the "News" section of the CAPS webpage (patientsafety.org), delved into the multifaceted nature of "harm." As defined within the context of the discussion, harm encompasses "Ill treatment; the impairment of physical or mental health (including that suffered from seeing, or hearing another person suffer ill treatment)." The session highlighted that the way patients, providers, and administrators respond in the wake of such incidents can significantly alter the trajectory, either mitigating the damage and facilitating healing or exacerbating an already distressing situation.
n
At a time when healthcare systems grapple with increasing complexity, diagnostic errors, and the pervasive "second victim" phenomenon among healthcare providers, the principles discussed offer a beacon of hope. The "Healing after Harm" webinar not only illuminated the profound human cost of medical incidents but also presented actionable frameworks for fostering accountability, empathy, and ultimately, healing within the healthcare ecosystem. The overwhelming interest and numerous questions from attendees underscored the urgent need for these innovative approaches, prompting CAPS to schedule a follow-up discussion to delve deeper into implementation strategies.
n
Main Facts: Redefining Response to Healthcare Harm
n
The "Healing after Harm" webinar, hosted by CAPS, served as a pivotal platform to introduce and explore transformative approaches to addressing adverse events in healthcare. Held on January 16th, the event brought together leading voices to advocate for a departure from conventional, often litigious, responses in favor of models that prioritize genuine healing and systemic learning.
n
The core message articulated throughout the session was that harm in healthcare is an inevitable, albeit tragic, reality, but the response to that harm is entirely within human control. Traditional responses, often characterized by a "deny and defend" posture, have historically proven ineffective in promoting true healing for patients, fostering trust, or supporting the well-being of healthcare providers involved. Instead, such approaches frequently lead to prolonged legal battles, emotional distress, and a breakdown of communication, hindering any meaningful opportunity for learning and improvement.
n
Mary Ellen Mannix, a passionate patient advocate and practitioner of Restorative Practice, shared her deeply personal journey, illustrating the limitations of a purely legalistic response to harm. Her powerful testimony set the stage for understanding Restorative Practice not merely as a theoretical concept but as a vital, human-centered methodology. She emphasized its capacity to mend fractured relationships and foster understanding among all stakeholders—patients, their families, caregivers, and institutional leadership—thereby addressing the emotional and psychological dimensions of harm that legal avenues often overlook.
n
Complementing Mannix’s insights, Martin Hatlie, a renowned expert in patient safety, elaborated on Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR) as a structured, proactive framework rooted in restorative principles. Hatlie positioned CANDOR as a practical application of these principles, demonstrating how healthcare organizations can implement transparent communication, thorough investigation, and compassionate resolution processes immediately following an adverse event. His presentation highlighted the tangible benefits of CANDOR, including its potential to reduce litigation, improve patient satisfaction, and cultivate a more open and just safety culture within hospitals.
n
The webinar provided a clear and compelling case for adopting these integrated approaches, arguing that by addressing harm holistically, healthcare institutions can move beyond blame to embrace a culture of empathy, accountability, and continuous improvement. The session concluded with an urgent call for continued dialogue and implementation, recognizing that the journey towards a truly restorative healthcare system is ongoing and requires collective commitment.
n
Chronology: From Personal Tragedy to Systemic Change
n
The narrative presented during the CAPS "Healing after Harm" webinar on January 16th meticulously traced the evolution of thought surrounding healthcare harm, from individual experiences of profound loss to the development of systematic frameworks for resolution.
n
The Genesis of a New Path: Mary Ellen Mannix’s Journey
n
Mary Ellen Mannix’s compelling story began with an unimaginable tragedy: the death of her son due to healthcare harm. In the aftermath of this devastating loss, Mannix, like many in her position, initially sought legal remedies, believing that justice and accountability would bring a measure of closure and healing. However, she recounted how the adversarial nature of the legal system, while perhaps offering financial compensation, ultimately failed to provide the emotional and psychological healing she desperately sought. The process often exacerbated feelings of isolation, anger, and unaddressed grief, perpetuating the very harm it aimed to resolve.
n
This profound personal experience spurred Mannix to seek alternative pathways to healing. Her quest led her to Restorative Practice, a social science traditionally applied in fields like criminal justice and education to mend relationships and communities fractured by harm. Mannix recognized the profound parallels between the relational breakdown in these contexts and the aftermath of healthcare errors. She dedicated herself to studying and adapting these principles, realizing their immense potential to address the complex emotional, ethical, and professional fallout of medical incidents.
n
In the webinar, Mannix explained how Restorative Practice operates by fostering open dialogue and mutual understanding among all affected parties. It moves beyond determining fault to exploring "who has been harmed, what are their needs, and whose obligation is it to meet those needs." By creating a safe space for individuals to share their experiences, express their pain, and articulate their needs, Restorative Practice aims to remove the pervasive element of shame that often silences providers and alienates patients. This process, she argued, is crucial for enabling all parties – patients, their families, caregivers, and providers – to collaboratively determine how to move forward, fostering a sense of shared responsibility and collective healing that legal processes rarely achieve.
n
The Evolution of CANDOR: A Framework for Restorative Action
n
Building on the foundational principles of Restorative Practice, Martin Hatlie, a stalwart in the patient safety community, detailed the evolution and implementation of Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR). Hatlie explained that CANDOR did not emerge in a vacuum but rather evolved from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality’s (AHRQ) Seven Pillars Tool Kit. This comprehensive toolkit, designed to help hospitals develop patient safety programs, laid critical groundwork for understanding the importance of open communication and system-level learning following adverse events.
n
CANDOR, as Hatlie elaborated, distilled these broader principles into a highly actionable and systematic process. While the original article did not list them, Hatlie emphasized three basic tenets that form the bedrock of CANDOR:
n
- n
- Early and Empathetic Communication: Immediately following an adverse event, healthcare organizations are encouraged to engage in open, honest, and compassionate communication with patients and their families. This includes acknowledging the harm, expressing empathy, and providing all known facts, even when the full picture is not yet clear. This proactive transparency builds trust and can prevent misunderstandings from escalating.
- Comprehensive Event Investigation and Analysis: Beyond communication, CANDOR mandates a swift, thorough, and transparent investigation into the incident. This is not about assigning blame but about understanding the contributing factors and systemic issues that led to the harm. The findings are then shared with the patient and family, explaining what happened and what steps will be taken to prevent recurrence.
- Support for Patients and Providers, and Fair Resolution: CANDOR places a high priority on providing support to both the harmed patient (e.g., medical, emotional, financial support for ongoing care) and the healthcare providers involved, who often suffer as "second victims." Critically, it also includes a commitment to offering fair and timely resolution, which may involve an apology, corrective actions, and appropriate compensation, often outside of the traditional adversarial litigation model.
n
n
n
n
Hatlie’s presentation provided compelling evidence of CANDOR’s growing acceptance and efficacy. He noted that over 200 hospitals across 35 states had already adopted CANDOR practices. This widespread implementation underscores a significant shift in the healthcare industry’s approach to harm, demonstrating a tangible commitment to transparency, learning, and patient-centered resolution. The success stories shared by Hatlie illustrated how CANDOR helps institutions reduce legal costs, improve patient satisfaction, and foster a culture where errors are viewed as opportunities for system improvement rather than occasions for blame.
n
Supporting Data: The Imperative for Change
n
The move towards restorative approaches like CANDOR is not merely an ethical imperative but a practical necessity, underscored by a wealth of data revealing the pervasive and devastating impact of healthcare harm. The figures paint a stark picture, highlighting the urgent need for more effective and humane resolution strategies.
n
The Alarming Scope of Healthcare Harm
n
Healthcare harm, encompassing medical errors, adverse events, and preventable complications, remains a leading cause of morbidity and mortality globally. Studies from organizations such as the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) consistently report that adverse events affect millions of patients worldwide each year. In the United States alone, estimates suggest that hundreds of thousands of deaths annually are attributable to preventable medical errors, placing medical error among the top causes of death. This staggering statistic often goes unrecognized, partly due to the complex and fragmented nature of reporting and analysis.
n
Beyond mortality, the financial burden of healthcare harm is immense. It includes the direct costs of extended hospital stays, additional treatments, and rehabilitation, as well as indirect costs associated with lost productivity and disability. Litigation costs, encompassing legal fees, settlements, and insurance premiums, further compound this financial strain on healthcare systems. While precise figures vary, conservative estimates place the annual cost of medical errors in the billions of dollars, diverting critical resources that could otherwise be invested in patient care and preventive measures.
The human cost, however, is immeasurable. Patients and their families endure profound physical, emotional, and psychological trauma, often leading to a loss of trust in the healthcare system. This erosion of trust can have long-lasting effects, impacting future care decisions and overall well-being. Furthermore, healthcare providers involved in adverse events often experience significant emotional distress, guilt, and even symptoms akin to post-traumatic stress disorder, a phenomenon widely recognized as the "second victim" syndrome. This impacts provider morale, contributes to burnout, and can lead to a defensive practice style, further hindering an open safety culture. The current system, often designed to protect institutions through silence, inadvertently harms everyone involved.
Evidence for Restorative Practice and CANDOR’s Efficacy
The theoretical underpinnings of Restorative Practice, borrowed from fields where it has demonstrably improved conflict resolution and community cohesion, translate powerfully to healthcare. In criminal justice, for instance, restorative justice programs have shown higher rates of victim satisfaction, offender accountability, and reduced recidivism compared to traditional punitive approaches. These principles—focused on repairing harm, involving all stakeholders, and addressing underlying needs—are directly applicable to the healthcare context.
Early data and anecdotal evidence from institutions implementing CANDOR demonstrate promising outcomes. Hospitals adopting CANDOR have reported:
- Reduced Litigation and Costs: By engaging in open communication and offering fair resolution early, many cases that would otherwise proceed to protracted and expensive litigation are resolved more efficiently and amicably. This proactive approach saves significant legal costs and insurance payouts.
- Improved Patient and Family Satisfaction: Patients and families consistently express greater satisfaction when they receive timely, honest explanations and sincere apologies, even in the face of tragic outcomes. The feeling of being heard, understood, and respected significantly contributes to their healing process.
- Enhanced Provider Well-being: By providing support to "second victims" and fostering an environment where errors are discussed openly for learning rather than punished, CANDOR helps mitigate the emotional toll on healthcare providers. This reduces burnout, improves morale, and encourages a more open reporting culture.
- Strengthened Safety Culture: CANDOR promotes a culture of transparency, accountability, and continuous learning. When errors are openly discussed and systematically investigated, it leads to tangible improvements in processes and systems, ultimately making care safer for everyone. The shift from a blame-focused to a learning-focused environment encourages reporting and proactive risk mitigation.
The 200+ hospitals and 35 states that have embraced CANDOR are not just adopting a new policy; they are investing in a fundamental cultural shift. This widespread adoption serves as compelling supporting data, indicating a growing recognition among healthcare leaders of the profound benefits these restorative approaches offer, not only for patients and providers but for the long-term sustainability and ethical integrity of healthcare itself.
Official Responses: Championing a Culture of Safety and Healing
The "Healing after Harm" webinar not only highlighted innovative solutions but also underscored the critical role of key organizations in championing these paradigm shifts within the complex healthcare ecosystem. The official responses, both explicit and implicit, signal a growing commitment to patient safety and holistic healing.
CAPS’s Steadfast Commitment to Patient Safety
The Collaborative Alliance for Patient Safety (CAPS) stands at the forefront of this movement. As the host of the "Healing after Harm" webinar, CAPS’s involvement is a direct reflection of its core mission: to improve patient safety and healthcare quality through collaboration, education, and advocacy. By providing a platform for experts like Mannix and Hatlie, CAPS actively facilitates the dissemination of best practices and encourages a national dialogue on critical issues. The organization’s commitment extends beyond merely hosting webinars; it is dedicated to fostering environments where transparency, learning, and patient-centered care are paramount.
CAPS’s decision to schedule a follow-up discussion for January 30, 2020, at Noon Central Time, further exemplifies its dedication to practical implementation. This immediate response to attendee questions highlights CAPS’s understanding that effective change requires ongoing support, detailed guidance, and a forum for practitioners to share challenges and successes. It demonstrates a proactive stance in ensuring that the theoretical insights presented translate into tangible improvements in clinical settings. The organization acts as a vital nexus, connecting researchers, practitioners, patients, and policymakers to collectively advance the patient safety agenda.
AHRQ’s Foundational Contribution to CANDOR
The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) plays a foundational role in the development and legitimization of CANDOR. As the lead federal agency charged with improving the safety and quality of America’s healthcare system, AHRQ’s research and tools provide the evidence base for many patient safety initiatives. Hatlie’s explanation of CANDOR’s evolution from AHRQ’s Seven Pillars Tool Kit is particularly significant. This connection underscores that CANDOR is not a novel, untested concept but a refinement of established patient safety principles, backed by rigorous research and federal endorsement.
AHRQ’s Seven Pillars Tool Kit provided a comprehensive framework for hospitals to understand and address patient safety incidents. Its principles—including reporting, investigation, communication, and system improvement—created the intellectual and practical scaffolding upon which CANDOR was built. This official backing from a reputable federal agency lends considerable weight to CANDOR’s credibility and encourages its adoption by healthcare organizations seeking evidence-based solutions. AHRQ’s ongoing work in disseminating best practices and supporting implementation initiatives further solidifies its role as a key driver in this transformative shift.
Broader Stakeholder Perspectives and Challenges
While direct official responses from other stakeholders were not explicitly detailed in the webinar, the widespread adoption of CANDOR in 35 states and over 200 hospitals implies a growing positive response from healthcare systems themselves. Hospital administrators and risk managers, initially cautious of transparent communication for fear of increased litigation, are increasingly recognizing the long-term benefits of CANDOR in terms of reduced legal costs, improved patient trust, and a healthier organizational culture.
Regulatory bodies, while not mandating CANDOR, are generally supportive of initiatives that enhance patient safety and transparency. Their evolving guidelines often encourage open communication and robust error reporting, aligning with the spirit of Restorative Practice and CANDOR. Patient advocacy groups, naturally, are strong proponents of approaches that prioritize patient voice, empathy, and fair resolution, seeing these models as a significant step towards greater patient empowerment and justice.
However, the transition to a restorative culture is not without its challenges. It requires a significant cultural shift within institutions, moving away from deeply ingrained defensive practices. This necessitates comprehensive training for all staff, strong leadership commitment, and sustained investment in resources. Legal and ethical frameworks also need to adapt to fully support these proactive and transparent resolution models. Despite these hurdles, the momentum generated by organizations like CAPS and AHRQ, coupled with the compelling evidence of benefits, suggests a collective will to overcome these obstacles and embed these restorative practices deeply within healthcare.
Implications: Reshaping the Future of Healthcare Safety
The "Healing after Harm" webinar articulated not just solutions for current challenges but also laid out profound implications for the future trajectory of healthcare safety and patient experience. The widespread adoption of Restorative Practice and CANDOR has the potential to fundamentally reshape how healthcare operates, moving towards a more ethical, empathetic, and ultimately safer system.
A Paradigm Shift in Patient Safety Culture
The most significant implication is the acceleration of a paradigm shift from a "deny and defend" mentality to one of "acknowledge, learn, and heal." For decades, the default response to adverse events in healthcare was often silence, defensiveness, and a reliance on legal maneuvering. This approach, while intended to protect institutions, inadvertently fostered an environment of mistrust, hindered learning from errors, and retraumatized both patients and providers.
Restorative Practice and CANDOR directly challenge this outdated paradigm. By prioritizing open communication, genuine apologies, thorough investigation, and compassionate resolution, they foster a culture where errors are viewed not as failures to be hidden but as critical learning opportunities. This shift is vital for building trust between patients and providers, which is the bedrock of effective healthcare. When patients feel heard and respected, and providers feel supported rather than blamed, the entire system benefits. This creates a psychological safety net that encourages reporting, enabling institutions to identify systemic vulnerabilities and implement effective preventive measures proactively. The removal of shame from the process, as highlighted by Mannix, is transformative, allowing all parties to engage authentically in the healing and learning process.
Future Directions for Healthcare Excellence
The widespread adoption of these models points towards several critical future directions for healthcare:
- Enhanced Patient Engagement and Empowerment: As restorative practices become more ingrained, patients will be increasingly empowered to participate meaningfully in the resolution process, leading to outcomes that are truly tailored to their needs and preferences. This fosters a sense of agency and reduces the feeling of being a passive recipient of care, or worse, a victim of circumstance.
- Improved Provider Well-being and Retention: By addressing the "second victim" phenomenon through robust support systems, healthcare organizations can significantly improve provider morale, reduce burnout, and enhance job satisfaction. A supportive, learning-oriented culture is crucial for retaining skilled professionals and fostering a compassionate workforce.
- Sustainable Financial Models: While the initial investment in implementing CANDOR requires resources for training and cultural change, the long-term financial implications are overwhelmingly positive. Reduced litigation costs, fewer insurance payouts, and improved patient loyalty contribute to a more sustainable and economically sound healthcare system.
- Continuous Systemic Improvement: The emphasis on transparent investigation and learning from errors will drive continuous improvement in clinical protocols, technology, and organizational processes. This proactive approach to safety will lead to fewer preventable harms over time, ultimately creating a safer environment for all.
- Ethical Leadership and Governance: The embrace of Restorative Practice and CANDOR signals a commitment to ethical leadership and governance within healthcare. It demonstrates a willingness to prioritize human dignity, transparency, and accountability over institutional self-preservation, thereby elevating the moral standing of the entire profession.
The CAPS "Healing after Harm" webinar was more than just an informational session; it was a rallying call for a more compassionate, transparent, and effective approach to patient safety. The upcoming follow-up discussion on Thursday, January 30, 2020, at Noon Central Time, provides a crucial opportunity for continued engagement and the practical exchange of ideas. Attendees are strongly encouraged to participate in this vital conversation, which will further explore the intricacies of implementing Restorative Practice and CANDOR and address specific questions from the healthcare community. This ongoing dialogue is essential for cementing these transformative practices as the standard of care, ensuring that healthcare truly lives up to its promise of healing for all.
Please join my meeting from your computer, tablet or smartphone.
https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/369235157
You can also dial in using your phone.
United States: +1 (872) 240-3212
Access Code: 369-235-157
