For Immediate Release
n
Washington, D.C. – January 27, 2020 – In an era where patient safety and healthcare quality are paramount, the conventional responses to medical harm often fall short, leaving a trail of unaddressed trauma for patients, their families, and even the dedicated healthcare providers involved. Recognizing this profound gap, the Collaborative Alliance for Patient Safety (CAPS) recently hosted a groundbreaking webinar, "Healing after Harm," on January 16, 2020. This pivotal event delved into the transformative potential of Restorative Practice and Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR) in fostering genuine healing and systemic improvement within healthcare settings.
n
The webinar, now accessible for review under the "News" section of the CAPS webpage (patientsafety.org), offered a compelling exploration of how a shift from a culture of blame to one of understanding and repair can fundamentally alter the landscape of healthcare after an adverse event. The session illuminated not only the theoretical underpinnings of these innovative approaches but also their practical application and demonstrable impact, sparking significant interest and prompting a follow-up discussion scheduled for January 30, 2020.
n
The Unseen Scars of Harm: Defining the Challenge in Healthcare
n
To fully appreciate the significance of Restorative Practice and CANDOR, it is crucial to first understand the profound and multifaceted nature of "harm" within healthcare. As defined during the webinar, harm extends beyond mere physical injury; it encompasses "ill treatment; the impairment of physical or mental health (including that suffered from seeing, or hearing another person suffer ill treatment)." This expansive definition underscores that medical errors, adverse events, or systemic failures inflict suffering not only on the patient directly affected but also on their loved ones, and often, on the healthcare professionals who were involved, even indirectly.
n
The statistics surrounding medical errors are sobering. While precise figures vary, studies consistently rank medical errors as a leading cause of death and injury, trailing only heart disease and cancer in some analyses. Beyond mortality, these incidents contribute to prolonged hospital stays, increased healthcare costs, and a significant erosion of trust between patients and providers. Yet, for too long, the default response to such harm has been rooted in an adversarial system focused on litigation, blame, and defensive posturing. This traditional approach, while aiming for accountability, frequently exacerbates the emotional distress of all parties, hindering learning and preventing true reconciliation and healing. It creates a climate where crucial information is withheld, errors are buried, and the opportunity for systemic improvement is lost.
n
The emotional toll on healthcare providers, often referred to as "second victims," is equally devastating. Clinicians involved in adverse events frequently experience profound guilt, anxiety, depression, and even post-traumatic stress. The fear of litigation, professional repercussions, and public scrutiny often forces them into silence, isolating them from necessary support and preventing them from processing the event in a healthy manner. This cycle of silence and shame perpetuates a system ill-equipped to learn from its mistakes, ultimately jeopardizing future patient safety. It is against this backdrop of widespread, often unacknowledged suffering that the principles of Restorative Practice and CANDOR emerge as vital pathways toward a more compassionate and effective response.
n
Chronology of Healing: From Personal Trauma to Systemic Change
n
The "Healing after Harm" webinar marked a significant moment in the ongoing efforts by CAPS to promote patient safety and ethical responses to adverse events. Held on January 16, 2020, the session brought together leading voices in the field to share insights and experiences, moving beyond theoretical discussions to practical applications.
n
The journey towards integrating restorative principles into healthcare is not a new one, but it has gained considerable momentum in recent years. Mary Ellen Mannix, a prominent advocate for Restorative Practice in healthcare, shared her deeply personal journey, which began with the tragic death of her son due to medical error. Her initial pursuit of legal remedies, a common and often necessary path for victims of medical malpractice, ultimately revealed its limitations in providing true healing. While legal processes can deliver justice in terms of compensation or accountability, Mannix found that they often failed to address the profound emotional and psychological wounds of all involved. The adversarial nature of litigation, with its emphasis on fault and blame, frequently deepened divisions rather than fostering understanding or resolution.
n
This personal quest for healing led Mannix to immerse herself in Restorative Practice, a social science discipline focused on improving and repairing relationships between people and within communities. Originating largely from the field of restorative justice in criminal contexts, its core tenets revolve around repairing harm, involving those affected, and transforming conflict into opportunities for growth and understanding. Mannix’s work has been instrumental in translating these principles into the complex, high-stakes environment of healthcare, demonstrating how they can offer a more holistic and human-centered approach to addressing medical harm. Her powerful narrative underscored the critical need for an alternative that prioritizes empathy, dialogue, and collective healing.
n
Complementing Mannix’s insights, Martin Hatlie, a recognized expert in patient safety and communication, provided a detailed exposition on the Communication and Optimal Resolution (CANDOR) process. Hatlie explained that CANDOR evolved directly from the AHRQ (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality) Seven Pillars Tool Kit, a comprehensive framework designed to help hospitals implement effective communication and resolution programs. The AHRQ’s work, initiated years prior, recognized the systemic failures in how healthcare organizations responded to harm and sought to provide a structured, proactive approach.
n
CANDOR, as a refined and widely adopted framework, embodies three basic tenets that underpin its effectiveness:
n
- n
- Early and Compassionate Communication: Prioritizing immediate, honest, and empathetic communication with patients and families following an adverse event, explaining what happened, expressing regret, and offering support.
- Proactive Investigation and Analysis: Promptly initiating a thorough, non-punitive investigation into the event to understand root causes, identify system vulnerabilities, and prevent recurrence. This includes transparent sharing of findings with affected parties.
- Fair and Timely Resolution: Offering fair compensation and resolution options to patients and families without requiring them to navigate a protracted and adversarial legal process. This can include apologies, financial offers, and commitments to system improvements.
n
n
n
n
These tenets represent a paradigm shift from the traditional "deny and defend" approach, fostering an environment where open dialogue, learning, and accountability can flourish. Hatlie’s presentation detailed how CANDOR provides a structured pathway for healthcare organizations to respond ethically and effectively to adverse events, ensuring that the needs of patients, families, and providers are met with compassion and a commitment to improvement.
n
The overwhelming response and the volume of questions from webinar attendees regarding the implementation of these Restorative Practice and CANDOR methodologies underscored the urgent need for further dialogue and practical guidance. This immediate and enthusiastic engagement directly led CAPS to schedule a follow-up discussion.
n
Supporting Data and Widespread Adoption
n
The efficacy and growing acceptance of CANDOR are not merely theoretical; they are supported by tangible implementation data and widespread adoption across the United States. Martin Hatlie shared compelling statistics, noting that CANDOR practices have been implemented in over 200 hospitals nationwide. Furthermore, these proactive communication and resolution strategies have taken root in facilities across thirty-five states, indicating a significant and expanding movement within the healthcare industry.
n
This widespread adoption is a testament to the recognized benefits of CANDOR, which include:
n
- n
- Reduced Litigation: By offering transparent communication and fair resolution proactively, CANDOR programs have been shown to significantly reduce the incidence of malpractice lawsuits, saving healthcare organizations considerable legal costs and reputational damage.
- Improved Patient and Family Satisfaction: Patients and families often prioritize understanding what happened and receiving a genuine apology over purely financial compensation. CANDOR fosters trust and provides a more humane pathway to resolution, leading to higher satisfaction rates even in the face of adverse outcomes.
- Enhanced Patient Safety Culture: The emphasis on open communication and learning from errors helps to dismantle the culture of silence and blame. This encourages reporting, thorough investigation, and the implementation of effective preventive measures, ultimately making healthcare safer for everyone.
- Support for Healthcare Providers: By providing a structured and empathetic process for addressing harm, CANDOR also offers vital support to "second victims." It removes the burden of individual blame, facilitates peer support, and helps providers process traumatic events, reducing burnout and fostering a more resilient workforce.
n
n
n
n
n
The foundational principle shared by both Restorative Practice and CANDOR is the crucial role of removing shame from the process. Shame, whether experienced by patients feeling betrayed or by providers feeling responsible, acts as a powerful barrier to healing and learning. It drives secrecy, defensive behaviors, and a reluctance to engage in open dialogue. By creating a safe space for all parties to acknowledge what happened, express their feelings, and participate in finding solutions, these practices allow for a transition from "what went wrong?" to "how do we move forward, together?" This shift is not merely about managing risk but about fundamentally transforming the human experience of medical harm, restoring dignity, and rebuilding trust.
Official Responses and Endorsements
The embrace of Restorative Practice and CANDOR represents a significant official response from within the healthcare system to the long-standing challenges of medical harm. Organizations like CAPS, with its mission to foster patient safety, are at the forefront of championing these methodologies. Their proactive hosting of webinars and follow-up discussions signals a clear commitment to educating healthcare leaders, providers, and policymakers about viable alternatives to traditional, often ineffective, responses.
The evolution of CANDOR from the AHRQ Seven Pillars Tool Kit is itself an endorsement from a federal agency dedicated to improving healthcare quality and safety. AHRQ’s investment in developing and disseminating such tools reflects a strategic recognition that improving communication and resolution processes is fundamental to achieving broader patient safety goals. The agency’s research and recommendations provide the evidentiary basis for the effectiveness of CANDOR, encouraging its adoption by hospitals and health systems nationwide.
Furthermore, the increasing number of state healthcare facilities adopting CANDOR practices indicates a grassroots, yet coordinated, official response at the institutional level. These facilities are making a conscious decision to invest in training, process redesign, and cultural shifts necessary to implement these programs successfully. This commitment often involves securing leadership buy-in, allocating resources for dedicated personnel (e.g., communication specialists, patient advocates), and fostering an organizational culture that values transparency, empathy, and continuous learning. The fact that 35 states have facilities engaging in CANDOR demonstrates a growing consensus among healthcare administrators and policymakers that these approaches are not merely "soft skills" but essential components of a robust and ethical patient safety infrastructure.
The active participation of experts like Mary Ellen Mannix and Martin Hatlie in the CAPS webinar further solidifies the official recognition of these practices. Their roles as thought leaders and implementers provide credibility and practical guidance, helping to bridge the gap between theory and real-world application. Their insights empower healthcare organizations to move beyond mere compliance and towards genuine transformation in how they manage and learn from adverse events.
Implications for the Future of Healthcare
The implications of widely adopting Restorative Practice and CANDOR in healthcare are profound and far-reaching, promising to reshape the very fabric of patient care and institutional response to harm.
1. A Culture of Trust and Transparency: By prioritizing open, honest communication and empathetic engagement, these practices can rebuild trust between patients, families, and healthcare providers, even after adverse events. This transparency fosters an environment where errors are seen as opportunities for learning, not just reasons for blame, leading to a more robust and proactive patient safety culture.
2. Enhanced Patient-Centered Care: Restorative Practice and CANDOR inherently place the patient and their experience at the center of the response to harm. By involving them in the resolution process and addressing their emotional and informational needs, these approaches align more closely with the principles of patient-centered care, ensuring that healing extends beyond physical recovery.
3. Improved Provider Well-being and Resilience: Healthcare professionals, often the "second victims" of medical errors, stand to benefit immensely. By creating a non-punitive environment for discussing errors and offering structured support, these practices can mitigate the psychological trauma experienced by providers, reduce burnout, and foster a more resilient and engaged workforce. This, in turn, can improve staff retention and overall morale.
4. Systemic Learning and Prevention: The emphasis on thorough investigation, root cause analysis, and transparent sharing of findings inherent in CANDOR facilitates deep organizational learning. By moving beyond individual blame to identify systemic vulnerabilities, healthcare organizations can implement more effective preventative measures, leading to a continuous cycle of improvement and fewer future harms.
5. Sustainable Financial and Operational Benefits: While the primary focus is on healing and safety, the reduction in litigation, associated legal costs, and insurance premiums offers significant financial benefits to healthcare organizations. Furthermore, improved patient and provider satisfaction can enhance reputation and market share, contributing to long-term operational sustainability.
6. Ethical Imperative: Beyond practical benefits, the adoption of Restorative Practice and CANDOR reflects an evolving ethical imperative within healthcare. It signifies a commitment to doing right by patients and providers, even when things go wrong, and upholding the moral responsibility to care for all those affected by medical harm.
The "Healing after Harm" webinar and the subsequent follow-up discussion represent critical steps in advancing these transformative practices. They provide a platform for sharing knowledge, addressing challenges, and fostering a community of practice dedicated to creating a safer, more compassionate, and more just healthcare system. The dialogue initiated by CAPS is not merely about reacting to harm but about proactively shaping a future where healing, learning, and trust are integral to every aspect of healthcare delivery.
Join the Conversation: Follow-Up Discussion Announced
The overwhelming interest generated by the "Healing after Harm" webinar has led CAPS to schedule a follow-up discussion, offering attendees and interested parties an invaluable opportunity to delve deeper into the complexities of Restorative Practice and CANDOR implementation. This session is designed to answer outstanding questions, share practical insights, and foster collaborative learning among participants.
Please join us to answer questions and talk about Restorative Practice and CANDOR!
Date: Thursday, January 30, 2020
Time: Noon Central Time
To join the meeting from your computer, tablet or smartphone, please use the following link:
https://global.gotomeeting.com/join/369235157
You can also dial in using your phone:
United States: +1 (872) 240-3212
Access Code: 369-235-157
This follow-up session is a crucial opportunity for healthcare professionals, administrators, patient advocates, and anyone invested in improving the response to medical harm to engage directly with experts and peers. By fostering an open and supportive environment for dialogue, CAPS continues its mission to champion innovative solutions that prioritize healing, transparency, and systemic improvement for the benefit of all stakeholders in the healthcare ecosystem. The journey towards a truly restorative healthcare system is ongoing, and these discussions are vital steps along that path.
